The Justice Yashwant Varma case has again raised questions about the in-house inquiry process and its shortcomings. Though the process is intended to preserve judicial integrity, questions regarding transparency and accountability still persist. The judiciary has to balance independence and accountability for misconduct by judges. Enhancing the system with improved guidelines and disclosure of inquiry findings to the public may assist in enhancing public faith in the justice system. The Justice Varma case is a reminder that the integrity of the judiciary is predicated on the ability of the judiciary to tackle allegations against members of the judiciary.